Good vibes only
Enjoy Fogarty's
Fogarty's, located at 227 Duval St, Key West, FL, offers a vibrant dining experience with a mix of fresh seafood and classic American fare. This charming eatery shines with dishes like the blackened snapper and peppered ahi tuna, both praised for their flavor and preparation. Customers rave about the outdoor seating, perfect for enjoying the warmth of Key West, and the attentive service that enhances every visit. While some may encounter occasional service hiccups, the welcoming atmosphere and consistently good food keep patrons coming back. Whether you’re savoring the key lime pie or a hearty burger, Fogarty's provides a delightful stop on Duval Street.
Taste the best
Discover Menu
Mahi Mahi Bites
Broccolini
Pecan Catch
Blackened Fish Tacos
Discover More
Fogarty's
If you find yourself wandering the vibrant streets of Key West, Florida, make sure to stop by Fogarty's, located right on the bustling Duval Street at 227 Duval St. This charming restaurant is a must-visit for anyone craving delicious seafood and a welcoming atmosphere. With its simple outdoor dining area and inviting decor, Fogarty's serves as a delightful oasis amidst the lively energy of the island.
When it comes to the food, Fogarty's is a culinary gem, famed for its fresh catch and flavorful dishes. Diners have raved about the blackened snapper, a standout dish that offers a rich and bold taste, perfect for seafood lovers. One enthusiastic customer noted the blackened shrimp wrap as full of flavor and cooked to perfection—proof that the chefs here prioritize quality and taste. Helen Giannakis enjoyed a variety of dishes, praising the healthiness and presentation of her meals, including the fish of the day dressed in a zesty lime sauce.
The menu is diverse enough to cater to different palates. Though some reviews hinted at occasional service hiccups, the consistent theme is the quality of the food. For light summer dining, the seared tuna salad is a refreshing option, albeit with a dressing that may overpower its subtle flavors. Meanwhile, the key lime pie concludes meals on a sweet note, even if many wish for a larger serving size.
Fogarty's doesn't just offer great food; it fosters a vibrant community spirit which is evident in the glowing remarks about their staff. Attentive service enhances the dining experience, creating an inviting atmosphere that encourages patrons to return often. As one reviewer noted, the staff's friendliness and attentiveness can make all the difference, making each visit feel special.
Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, Fogarty's strives to provide a memorable experience, showcasing the best of Key West's culinary scene. From the flavor-packed dishes to the lively ambiance, it's clear why many consider Fogarty's not just a restaurant, but a cherished local staple. Don't miss out on this delightful destination during your next visit to Key West!
Shared Experiences
Guestbook
“ My blackened snapper was awesome. It was the fresh catch so they might not always have it. It was so good that I'm giving this 5 stars despite the awful service. Basically, the server was one of the worst we've ever had. I doubt she'll be there long anyway so there's no reason to list out all the issues. I'm sure getting good staff is really tough. ”
“ Fogarty’s on Duval Street was a solid lunch spot, especially with its indoor seating on a hot day. The ahi tuna salad was beautifully presented but had far too much lettuce compared to the amount of tuna. The chicken tenders were decent, nothing exceptional but still satisfying. The blackened shrimp wrap was definitely the standout dish — full of flavor and cooked perfectly. While the dolphin sandwich lacked seasoning, the tartar sauce helped bring it to life, and the fun drinks made the overall experience enjoyable. ”
“ We went for dinner in the main drag of Key West and noticed this cute period house and simple outdoor dining area with a couple of bars. We reviewed the menu and ordered with Elia - a very attentive service staff member. We had the tuna salad, fish of day with lime sauce and steak dishes. It was really healthy, presentable and tasty. They even cater to gluten free. ”
“ The seared tuna salad was tasty even though too much dressing made it soggy. We didn’t want anything too heavy & the salad was nice for a warm summer’s evening. We also had the key lime pie which was delicate & tasty but very small in size. (Not sure why the price was increased by $2). ”
“ Zona, you get 5 stars too! You are a great server. I have never had a bad meal here. This time I got a cheeseburger with fries. Sitting outside watching others enjoy their day made it even better. When I realized the Conch Republic parade was going to be happening, I decided to stick around and ordered a bottle of wine. ”